Nelson: Carbon tax charade about saving Liberals, not planet

Article content material

As with many issues at present, carbon taxes are extra about politics than any sensible answer to a significant issue.

At first look, they appear fairly logical as authorities coverage. If you wish to scale back using one thing — whether or not it’s gasoline, cigarettes or consuming pizza — then jack up the worth till you finally accomplish your objective.

Article content material

However in actuality, the imposition of those inexperienced levies won’t ever attain a degree the place folks in the reduction of utilization sufficient to have an considerable impact on humanity’s manufacturing of carbon. Any politician trying to take action can be run out of workplace lengthy earlier than the tax was excessive sufficient to alter behaviour to such an extent it made any noticeable, environmental distinction.

Article content material

That’s very true in Canada, the place a comparatively small inhabitants unfold out throughout an enormous and sometimes frozen land mass couldn’t survive, by no means thoughts thrive, with out delivering a slightly massive carbon footprint.

Shrinking that footprint by any sizable diploma would depart us stranded, freezing at nighttime, permitting the a lot bigger populations of nations akin to China, India and our southern neighbours to shortly gobble up what tiny drop in emissions our self-sacrifice resulted in, emitting barely a burp of gratitude within the course of.

Nonetheless, this assured failure doesn’t cease our present federal authorities from pretending it’s steadfastly saving the planet, despite the fact that it hasn’t hit any self-imposed emission-reduction goal since first grabbing the best perch aboard the stop-global-warming bandwagon virtually a decade in the past.

That symbolism is why Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s regime jacked up taxes once more on the acceptable date of April 1. (How a lot additional we pay at present for heating, energy and gasoline is compounded by the extra prosaic politics of our provincial authorities, in steadily jettisoning the assorted breaks it gave us on pure fuel, electrical energy and gasoline through the run-up to final 12 months’s election. Blatant self-interest, after all, however a minimum of Premier Danielle Smith’s bunch didn’t faux they have been saving Alberta from some future fiery armageddon, however as an alternative merely reminded us of the inherent cynicism of politicians once they want your vote versus once they don’t.)

Article content material

Article content material

By way of cynicism, the federal Liberals have by no means taken a again seat to anybody relating to that doubtful political advantage.

Earlier this 12 months, the Grits put to mattress any lingering doubt the surroundings was past the sordid attain of day-to-day governance once they exempted heating oil from the carbon tax. This got here after determined pleas from their Maritimes MPs, anxiously watching assist plummet as a result of additional price these levies positioned upon beforehand loyal voters.

In typical Liberal trend, this exemption for heating oil — closely utilized in Atlantic Canada, in contrast to on the prairies the place there are additionally far fewer Grit MPs — got here regardless of years of preaching about following the worldwide warming science. As an alternative, Trudeau’s authorities merely adopted the polls.

The typical Canadian isn’t too environmentally steadfast both. A current Leger ballot confirmed greater than two-thirds oppose any additional enhance in inexperienced levies. It simply took a spike in inflation to remind us the price of residing issues greater than the specter of some blistering future summer time.

Article content material

So, if carbon taxes are too restricted to curb particular person emissions — Setting Minister Steven Guilbeault admits any impact can’t even be calculated — whereas most Canadians now not favour them, how come they nonetheless exist?

Effectively, nothing will get a authorities extra excited than doling out cheques to voters, particularly if the money really comes from earlier choosing those self same recipients’ pockets. Such is the case with these carbon rebates, sweetly deposited into our financial institution accounts every quarter.

Bean counters estimate we’re worse off total after paying the tax and getting rebates, however the former is available in smaller increments unfold throughout many payments, whereas the latter is a comparatively juicy fee courtesy of our benevolent federal authorities, one you could possibly repay within the voting sales space down the highway.

The carbon tax charade isn’t about saving the planet in any respect. It’s about saving the Liberals.

Article content material