Varcoe: Oil price gives Alberta firepower to cut debt and spending

Article content material

Saving, spending or paying off debt?

Article content material

Budgets are all about decisions and Finance Minister Travis Toews has at the least three huge ones to make in his new funds Tuesday as Alberta has loads of monetary firepower at hand given excessive oil costs, a robust economic system and quickly declining debt ranges.

Article content material

With one other surplus anticipated within the 2023-24 funds — economists and credit standing companies say that needs to be the case except spending goes wild — that leaves Toews with some alternate options.

Ought to the county use the majority of any new surplus to proceed decreasing its bank card invoice, put vital cash into the Heritage Financial savings Belief Fund, or ship extra {dollars} to program spending and infrastructure investments?

What’s the proper mixture at this second in time?

Article content material

“The county’s funds are within the midst of what seems to be a really sturdy turnaround,” Douglas Offerman, an analyst at Fitch Rankings, stated Monday from New York.

“Let’s put it this manner – it is a huge drawback to have whenever you’re discussing one of the best ways to make use of a surplus. It speaks volumes about the place your scenario compares to 2 years in the past.”

In early 2021, the pandemic nonetheless had Alberta’s economic system on the ropes.

Within the February funds that 12 months, complete taxpayer-backed debt was projected to rise to a whopping $116 billion by the tip of 2021-2022, up from $98 billion.

A staggering $18.2 billion price of pink ink was predicted in that doc.

Happily, that did not occur. Commodity costs rose and the labor market recovered from the preliminary pandemic hit, with a surplus lastly recorded in that fiscal 12 months.

Article content material

Over the previous 12 months, oil costs have soared within the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Benchmark US oil costs closed at US$75.68 per barrel on Monday.

Extra oil sands initiatives have additionally shifted to paying a better royalty charge, sending extra income to provincial coffers. Alberta can be turning into extra delicate to modifications in oil costs with rising crude manufacturing.

Each $1-per-barrel change in benchmark oil costs over the course of the 12 months might doubtlessly swing authorities income by $600 million or extra, College of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe stated.

“At $76 oil, that will put us at about $18 billion in useful resource income, if it lasted for the complete fiscal 12 months,” he stated on Friday. “Regardless of oil costs falling from their highs final 12 months, we’re nonetheless in a really sturdy place.”

Article content material

The UCP introduced final 12 months that it might pay down $13.4 billion in debt in the course of the present fiscal 12 months, bringing taxpayer-backed debt to a projected $79.8 billion by the tip of March 2023, in response to the province’s mid-term replace in November.

Offerman identified that with rising rates of interest and fewer borrowing wanted, “from a steadiness sheet standpoint, it is super. You do deserve the financial savings from diminished curiosity on debt.”

DBRS Morningstar senior vice chairman Travis Shaw stated it is cheap to count on one other funds surplus in Alberta given the place commodity costs are, however there’s rising stress to spend extra.

“We at the moment are on this period of persistently excessive inflation, which creates completely different pressures and completely different calls for on the federal government, so how will they reply to that?” Shaw stated.

Article content material

For enterprise operators, the reply to those decisions needs to be clear, stated the Alberta Chambers of Commerce.

It surveyed greater than 500 enterprise operators final summer season about what needs to be carried out with rising useful resource revenues and requested them to rank two priorities.

Sixty p.c selected to pay down debt and 51 p.c favored extra infrastructure funding.

In the meantime, 35 p.c opted for diminished taxes, 34 p.c needed to save lots of the excess – as within the Heritage Fund – and 22 p.c needed the federal government to extend spending on public providers.

“On the finish of the day, we’re nonetheless considerably in debt as a province,” stated Jason Leslie of the Alberta Chambers of Commerce.

Nonetheless, there are calls to spend on key areas equivalent to healthcare, schooling and affordability measures.

Article content material

NDP member Kathleen Ganley stated the price of residing for Albertans is rising and the province’s unemployment charge stays above the nationwide common.

“Albertans may have a surplus — that is due to excessive power costs,” she informed reporters Saturday.

“These funds belong to Albertans they usually have to be invested in the way forward for the individuals of this province.”

The province must be cautious about spending hike applications based mostly on rising commodity costs, stated Michael Holden, chief economist of the Enterprise Council of Alberta.

The group would like to see the federal government “closely leaning” in the direction of debt discount within the close to time period, whereas transferring in the direction of better financial savings over time.

“We can’t lock in will increase in long-term working spending based mostly on a single improve” in useful resource income, he added.

Article content material

The UCP authorities has already indicated more cash is coming for psychological well being and addictions funding, and for the well being care system.

There are additionally requires better funding.

For instance, the Pathways Alliance — a bunch of main oil sands producers — is wanting into whether or not there will probably be provincial incentives to go forward with its $16.5-billion carbon seize, utilization and storage venture.

“We need to see a sign that that is the path the federal government goes,” stated Mark Cameron, a vice chairman of Pathways Alliance.

Article content material

In November’s replace, the province predicted the excess for the present fiscal 12 months would attain $12.3 billion, then drop to $5.6 billion for the upcoming funds 12 months that begins in April.

Whereas the nation might be heading into recession, RBC Economics predicts Alberta’s economic system will develop 1.9 per cent this 12 months — the very best within the nation — although down from 4.9 per cent in 2022.

“We count on Alberta’s 2023 funds to disclose one more optimistic fiscal outlook for the province. Sturdy income from useful resource royalties will bode effectively for the province,” stated RBC economist Rachel Battaglia.

“With that stated, we don’t count on the province to report the identical astonishing surplus as earlier than.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

cvarcoe@postmedia.com