Varcoe: It won’t take long to fill up TMX pipeline. What comes next?

Article content material

Going through transportation bottlenecks — and a divisive pipeline debate — for years, the Canadian oil trade is now eagerly awaiting the startup of the Trans Mountain pipeline enlargement.

As building on the $30.9-billion venture attracts to a detailed and it’s anticipated to start industrial operations subsequent quarter, analysts and trade leaders anticipate it gained’t be too lengthy earlier than the pipeline — together with different oil export traces in Western Canada — start to replenish.

Article content material

Article content material

After which, the persistent situation of inadequate transportation capability may rear its head, as soon as once more.

“The availability is coming, and in very quick order Western Canada will in all probability be north of 90 per cent (pipeline) utilization fee once more,” stated Kevin Birn, a vice-president with S&P International Commodity Insights.

“In the long run, we nonetheless see Western Canada placing quite a lot of strain on its takeaway system . . . We see it filling up progressively over the subsequent 18 to 24 months. By the top of 2025, the system is trying fairly full.”

On Friday, Calgary-based Enbridge reported that its Mainline pipeline system transported a median of three.2 million barrels per day (bpd) through the fourth quarter, an all-time excessive.

Even with the Trans Mountain enlargement coming on-line this yr, the Mainline system is anticipated to ship about three million bpd in 2024.

“The Mainline has been mainly full for 75 years. So, it’s a pattern that continues,” Colin Gruending, Enbridge’s president of liquids pipelines, informed analysts Friday on a convention name.

Western Canadian petroleum producers have grappled with transportation constraints for years amid surging oilsands manufacturing.

Article content material

Article content material

Since 2010, Alberta’s oil output has risen from practically two million bpd to a median of three.8 million bpd final yr, a document degree. Throughout that point, a number of giant pipeline proposals have failed, together with Enbridge’s Northern Gateway growth and TC Vitality’s Keystone XL.

Nonetheless, the completion of Enbridge’s Line 3 Alternative Undertaking in 2021 added 370,000 bpd of pipeline capability out of Western Canada to the USA.

The Trans Mountain enlargement (TMX), which was submitted to the federal power regulator in 2013, will nearly triple the prevailing line’s capability by 590,000 bpd.

“We’re quick pipe proper now. As soon as TMX comes on, we are going to possible be lengthy (with extra) export capability, in all probability till that 2026 timeframe,” stated analyst Nate Heywood of ATB Capital Markets.

“We do suppose that pipelines can be comparatively full by the mid-decade.”

Article content material

Whereas some consultants thought the startup of TMX would reduce into Enbridge’s Mainline volumes with added competitors, Gruending famous provide has “structurally and completely grown” with rising demand lately.

In 2023, western Canadian oil provide elevated by 150,000 barrels per day, he famous. This yr, provide will develop by between 250,000 and 300,000 bpd — with one other 200,000 added to the combo subsequent yr.

At instances up to now decade, a scarcity of transportation capability has led to a steep worth differential between U.S. benchmark crude and Western Canadian Choose heavy oil.

The low cost reached as excessive as US$50 a barrel at one level in 2018 throughout a interval of pipeline constraint.

(Provincial knowledge signifies the value differential final yr averaged US$18.65 a barrel.)

“There isn’t a doubt we’re going to want extra pipe inside this decade,” stated Tristan Goodman, president of the Explorers and Producers Affiliation of Canada.

“Demand for oil continues to extend on a world foundation, yr after yr after yr.”

Whereas the Worldwide Vitality Company has forecast oil demand will peak this decade, it initiatives international consumption will improve by 1.2 million barrels per day this yr, after hitting a document of practically 102 million bpd in 2023.

Article content material

Hal Kvisle, former CEO of Trans Canada Pipelines, famous producers in Western Canada have added incremental output lately by taking steps to debottleneck oilsands operations, reasonably than constructing new greenfield initiatives.

He expects progress will proceed, however doesn’t foresee trade gamers proposing main new export pipelines, given the hurdles and federal insurance policies dealing with the sector.

Nonetheless, there may be extra fuel pipeline capability heading east and south that could possibly be transformed to maneuver oil, and there’s additionally the potential to maneuver extra oil to the U.S. by prepare.

“We may simply add one or two million barrels a day (from) the oilsands by way of new initiatives, however folks aren’t going to kick off these new initiatives except they’ve some consolation round federal insurance policies and a few consolation there may be going to be pipe to get the oil to market,” stated Kvisle.

“I believe we are going to construct extra pipelines and I believe Canadian oilsands manufacturing will develop, however I don’t see any of that taking place within the subsequent 5 years — apart from the little incremental issues.”

As soon as TMX is accomplished, complete pipeline export capability in Canada will attain greater than 4.8 million bpd, Birn stated.

Article content material

Midstream firms may even proceed to seek out methods to broaden their present programs with smaller-scale initiatives.

“We really feel the capability egress can be pretty balanced . . . but when extra is required, we’ll handle that by optimizing our system,” Enbridge stated in an announcement.

“Now we have 200,000 bpd of enlargement potential on the Mainline that entails debottlenecking and small-scale capability additions.”

Within the longer run, will the dialogue flip again to constructing new pipelines — throughout an period of decarbonization and rising local weather issues — or will that debate finish with the completion of TMX?

“We are going to at all times develop manufacturing if the world needs our manufacturing . . . The issue for me is that after Trans Mountain, I don’t see how anyone goes to construct one other pipeline,” stated Richard Masson, former CEO of the Alberta Petroleum Advertising and marketing Fee.

“The long-term reply is we now have to discover a stability in how shortly we develop, with how a lot market entry we are able to get. It’s a giant problem.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

cvarcoe@postmedia.com

Article content material