Varcoe: Alberta power market shakeup could save consumers billions

Article content material

New analysis inspecting the overhaul of Alberta’s energy market concludes provincial reforms will result in financial savings for customers — as a lot as $1 billon inside three years and probably $8 billion over a decade, as a consequence of decrease electrical energy costs.

Nevertheless, the examine says modifications to restrict the follow of “financial withholding” by giant energy turbines are pointless as electrical energy costs have been already falling, and warns that makes an attempt to restrict costs will come “on the expense of investor confidence.”

Article content material

Article content material

Electrical energy consulting agency EDC Associates Ltd. carried out the examine after the UCP authorities introduced a sequence of steps to overtake the province’s deregulated energy market, together with short-term measures that kick on this summer time and proposals for longer-term reforms.

It discovered that the instant strikes will decrease wholesale electrical energy costs, which are actually anticipated to common about $74 per megawatt-hour (MWh) this yr, down eight per cent from its earlier forecast.

An identical decline is seen in 2025, with a seven per drop cent projected in 2026.

For customers, this might translate into $430 million in energy value financial savings over one yr, reaching nearly $1.1 billion over a three-year interval — and greater than $8 billion over 10 years based mostly on EDC’s modelling, mentioned Alex Markowski, senior vitality market analyst with the Calgary-based agency.

Turbines will lose the above income potential, which is able to create a much less enticing surroundings for constructing energy tasks in Alberta, he mentioned.

“On the finish of the day, these modifications drive costs down, which is sweet for customers,” Markowski mentioned in an interview.

Article content material

Article content material

“But it surely’s a double-edged sword as a result of something good for the customers is dangerous for the generator, so you need to attempt to discover that proper stability between each.”

EDC has additionally lowered its future renewable vitality development forecast by 20 per cent by 2040.

“Costs have been coming down anyway. The issue was fixing itself,” EDC president Duane Reid-Carlson mentioned Tuesday.

“That is dangerous coverage . . . For the federal government to step in and do all this stuff and create a halt on funding — we don’t want the funding in the mean time, however it’ll kill funding for a really important period of time.”

Article content material

Final month, Alberta Utilities Minister Nathan Neudorf introduced a set of short-term measures to restrict value volatility within the provincial energy market.

The province and Alberta Electrical System Operator (AESO) adopted it up with longer-term proposals to restructure Canada’s solely deregulated electrical energy market.

The interim modifications take impact in July and can stay in place till 2027. They’ll see the province set up guidelines to restrict the follow of financial withholding by giant pure gasoline electrical energy turbines.

Financial withholding is permitted in Alberta, permitting turbines to supply electrical energy at costs “sufficiently above marginal value that the generator is just not dispatched, and the pool value is elevated in consequence,” in response to the Market Surveillance Administrator.

The modifications will prohibit financial withholding by capping the provide value permitted by giant turbines, if their internet revenues exceed a predefined degree.

Underneath the broader reforms being proposed, the province may create new guidelines that embrace day-ahead pricing for the wholesale energy market.

Article content material

The AESO is consulting on the proposed modifications, and technical design is anticipated to be wrapped up later this yr.

After a interval of decrease energy costs in Alberta final decade — wholesale electrical energy costs averaged under $20 per MWh in 2016 — they’ve averaged greater than $100 per MWh through the previous three years.

Nevertheless, costs are projected to drop this yr as extra gas-fired and renewable technology comes on-line. With the provincial modifications, the EDC report has lowered its 15-year forecast of energy costs by $9 per MWh, or eight per cent.

In an interview, Neudorf mentioned Tuesday that he’s happy to see costs are anticipated to fall for customers in Alberta.

“We needed stability and, actually, we hoped for a little bit of an easing in these costs,” Neudorf mentioned.

“Affordability may be very, crucial. However we need to be sure that there’s stability for business, in order that they will see a long-term return on these investments.”

Neudorf maintained the province is making an attempt to strike a stability with its modifications, however mentioned it’s the federal authorities’s push for electrical energy grids to achieve net-zero standing by 2035, as an alternative of 2050, that may rattle funding.

Article content material

On the longer-term reforms, EDC calls the modifications pointless, saying the first driving elements are federal carbon coverage and “hyper-accelerated renewable development.”

Alberta has captured the majority of all new renewable vitality funding in Canada over the previous two years.

“Whereas we do forecast renewable development slowing post-2025, we don’t forecast it coming to an entire standstill,” the report states.

The EDC report says renewable development might be throttled again due to expectations of upper transmission prices, decrease income expectations and the unknown impact of the province’s new 35-kilometre buffer zones being established to guard “pristine viewscapes.”

Except for development in wind and photo voltaic, the province is anticipating to see a surge of gasoline energy this yr from tasks which have been advancing.

“Though there isn’t a query that these coverage selections will certainly chill investor confidence available in the market, Alberta is presently so full up with provide that the consequences doubtless received’t be seen instantly,” the report factors out.

“That mentioned, it’s a calculated gamble. It took a few years to draw traders to Alberta . . . there isn’t a assure that they are going to return in the event that they determine to withdraw.”

Article content material

Individually, vitality analytics agency Enverus Intelligence Analysis has recognized 43 deliberate renewable vitality tasks in Alberta that may very well be “in danger” of being suspended due to new laws surrounding new wind and photo voltaic developments.

In February, the province introduced it could create buffer zones round protected areas the place wind generators won’t be permitted. It’s going to additionally restrict new renewable growth on prime agricultural land, until the developer can present that farming and livestock can coexist with renewables constructed on the location.

Ryan Luther, a director on Enverus’ vitality transition analysis group, mentioned the constraints round pristine viewscapes aren’t as giant as was initially thought, however he referred to as restrictions round agricultural land “fairly punitive.”

“I might nonetheless anticipate some renewables to get constructed, however definitely a slowdown.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

cvarcoe@postmedia.com

Article content material