Suncor investors face opposing climate proposals at May annual meeting

Article content material

Traders at Suncor Vitality annual conferences have seen loads of proposals and debate in regards to the firm’s local weather plans over time.

However on the upcoming AGM in Could, Suncor will face duelling shareholder proposals that come from distinctly totally different instructions.

Article content material

One seeks extra disclosure about Suncor’s local weather transition technique.

The opposite requires the oilsands producer to scrap its dedication to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050.

Article content material

“I haven’t seen something like that earlier than, but it surely simply goes to point out how controversial all of it is,” mentioned Laura Lau, chief funding officer of Brompton Group, which owns shares in Suncor.

Whereas america has seen a pushback lately in opposition to ESG (setting, social and governance) and efforts to have traders exit fossil gasoline firms attributable to local weather considerations, there have been far fewer such initiatives in Canada.

However at Suncor’s annual assembly, Suncor traders will vote on a proposal by InvestNow Inc., a non-profit group that “challenges the divestment motion and advocates for funding in Canada’s oil and gasoline sector,” in line with Suncor’s new administration proxy round.

“Internet zero by 2050 means huge declines in using coal, oil and gasoline,” InvestNow says in its supporting assertion.

“It commits to radical adjustments in very quick time frames. It isn’t legally required and has no clear connection to rising shareholder worth.”

Gina Pappano, who shaped InvestNow and beforehand was the top of the market intelligence division on the Toronto Inventory Alternate, mentioned she believes net-zero targets are akin to divesting in Canada’s oil and gasoline sector.

Article content material

Article content material

“As a shareholder, I would like the oil and gasoline firms to do what they do greatest, particularly in Canada, which is take oil out of the bottom, probe for oil and gasoline, get it to nations that want it,” Pappano mentioned in an interview.

“We’ve got a number of the highest, most stringent environmental laws on the earth. I would like them to fulfill the rising calls for and never be constrained from a enterprise perspective by these arbitrary targets.”

Pappano mentioned she’s not asking Suncor or different firms to cease bettering their operations and believes they need to cut back greenhouse gasoline emissions, however they want funding to take action.

On the similar assembly on Could 7, the group Traders for Paris Compliance calls on Suncor shareholders to help a decision that requires the corporate to reveal audited outcomes that assess a variety of local weather transition eventualities, dangers and monetary implications.

Such information would come with Suncor’s prices and valuations, projections for long-term oil and carbon costs, and future asset retirement obligations. The Worldwide Vitality Company has forecast international oil and gasoline demand will peak later this decade, and nations similar to Canada are striving to deal with local weather change with net-zero targets.

Article content material

“What we’re asking for on this decision is, begin exhibiting us that you’re prepared for it, that you’re making these actions,” mentioned Duncan Kenyon with Traders for Paris Compliance.

“How are you prepared for the power transition?”

For its half, Suncor’s board and administration suggest traders reject each proposals.

Responding to InvestNow, the corporate mentioned it’s dedicated to being a part of the power transition and decarbonizing its enterprise.

As for the proposal by the Traders for Paris Compliance, Suncor identified it has produced annual local weather stories since 2017, and present disclosure “gives perception into local weather technique, danger, alternative and efficiency,” it states within the administration proxy round.

Article content material

South of the border, a backlash in opposition to ESG targets and disinvestment efforts has grown.

Final week, the Texas Everlasting College Fund terminated two funding providers contracts with BlackRock to handle greater than US$8 billion of funds.

In 2021, Texas handed a legislation that forestalls state companies from investing in corporations that it deems have taken actions to penalize or restrict power firms that don’t pledge to fulfill environmental requirements, past state and federal legislation. (In a letter to shareholders on Tuesday, BlackRock CEO Larry Fink mentioned the agency has by no means supported divesting from conventional power corporations.)

Different states have pushed again in opposition to ESG measures, together with Florida, Oklahoma and Utah.

“What we’re seeing much more of — each in Canada and america — is type of contrasting proposals, each pro-sustainability and anti-sustainability,” mentioned Lindsey Stewart, director of funding stewardship analysis at Morningstar.

“It’s attention-grabbing to see it at a fossil gasoline firm, Suncor, this time round.”

Nonetheless, he famous the common anti-ESG shareholder proposal nonetheless will get lower than 5 per cent help.

Article content material

However Jason Kenney, who as Alberta’s premier criticized banks and funds that stopped providing providers or divested from the oilsands, mentioned he expects to see mounting strain on funding corporations that take such steps sooner or later.

“Cumulatively, (the pushback has) had an affect. I believe the larger affect has been merely pushed by returns — the superior returns of many oil and gasoline firms within the final two or three years,” Kenney mentioned in an interview Tuesday.

“I’m glad to listen to that there are folks representing the bottom-line pursuits of traders now, to sort of equalize the controversy, as a result of I believe it’s been, lately, lopsided.”

Suncor dedicated in Could 2021 to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050.

It’s additionally one of many founding members of the Pathways Alliance, a bunch of six oilsands operators working collectively to achieve net-zero emissions.

Pappano mentioned her group, which submitted anti-divestment proposals to Canada’s largest banks final yr, was shocked to see Suncor oppose its shareholder proposal.

Kenyon mentioned he hasn’t seen duelling local weather resolutions earlier than at an annual assembly of a Canadian oil firm, however isn’t shocked. “What’s the outdated expression: Your greatest defence is an efficient offence,” he mentioned.

Article content material

Martha Corridor Findlay, director of the College of Calgary’s College of Public Coverage, who beforehand was Suncor’s chief local weather officer, mentioned the divestment motion “utterly ignores” the fact of rising international demand for oil and gasoline.

Canadian oil and gasoline firms are on the prime of the charts on ESG measures, though they should proceed taking additional local weather motion, she mentioned.

“Divestment doesn’t make any sense. However that mentioned, anti-divestment doesn’t make sense, both. Everyone knows that local weather change is a major drawback for the world,” mentioned Corridor Findlay.

“Kudos for the businesses which are recognizing average voices, which are primarily based on proof, and primarily based on a recognition of what the world wants.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

cvarcoe@postmedia.com

Article content material