Industry gives mixed reviews to UCP incentives for well cleanup pilot

Article content material

Though the play has not but formally opened, harsh critiques are pouring in for Premier Danielle Smith’s new plan to wash up outdated wells.

Article content material

The province plans to supply royalty credit to eligible petroleum producers in a pilot program, giving them a carrot to speed up spending to wash up and rehabilitate outdated oil and gasoline wells and legacy websites.

Article content material

“There was plenty of misinformation about this system,” Vitality Minister Peter Guthrie mentioned in an interview Monday.

“A lot of the teams we sat down with, as soon as they heard the main points . . . (replied) that, ‘Hey, it is a program that has advantage.’ “

Nonetheless, most of the early critiques are scathing.

“It is a silly program,” mentioned one Oilpatch CEO, who didn’t wish to be recognized.

“This harms our long-term status. We attempt to painting a imaginative and prescient that cleans us up after ourselves, and for probably the most half, we’re. Yearly I allocate some huge cash to wash issues and it will increase yearly. I believe it takes our status down.”

Article content material

A overview final week from Scotiabank echoed comparable issues, noting that “detrimental reactions to the proposal thus far abound”.

“Whereas we see the potential for choose corporations to learn from this system, we imagine it has the potential to generate detrimental public sentiment in the direction of the sector,” mentioned the report from Scotiabank analysts.

Different criticisms centered on the province transferring away from the polluter-pays precept by providing incentives.

“You are giving individuals a royalty, you are giving them authorities {dollars}, to fund one thing they’ve already dedicated to doing,” mentioned College of Alberta power economist Andrew Leach.

“I do not imagine in incentives to (do) it. I imagine in having timelines” that require the cleanup of older wells, added Paul McLauchlin, president of the Rural Municipalities of Alberta, who may be very a lot from Ponoka Nation.

Article content material

The province’s Legal responsibility Administration Incentive Program, previously often known as R-Star, is a pilot that can present as much as $100 million in royalty credit to corporations — however provided that they comply with meet their obligatory annual spending necessities for such work as set out by the Alberta exceed. Vitality regulator, Guthrie mentioned.

(The regulator set the industry-wide shutdown spending objective at $700 million in 2023, up from $422 million final 12 months.)

Royalty credit can solely be used for manufacturing from new wells, which ought to result in extra drilling exercise and jobs within the oilfield companies sector, the minister mentioned.

Article content material

Guthrie estimates that about 1,600 wells might qualify, with this system’s standards based mostly on addressing inactive wells that haven’t produced oil or gasoline for no less than 20 years and have been drilled earlier than 1980.

The power minister mentioned eligible producers will should be on high of their provincial royalty and AER funds, in addition to floor lease funds and tax payments to municipalities.

“It is about going past the obligatory spending, so . . . are we additional forward with this program? Will we get extra websites cleared, 12 months after 12 months? And the reply to that query is sure,” he mentioned.

“I imagine that this system, on its deserves, has the flexibility to extend the velocity of clean-up within the province.”

Whereas everybody desires to see inactive wells handled correctly, the query is who pays for them and the way shortly the work is finished.

Article content material

In line with the AER, there have been about 464,000 complete wells within the province final 12 months, with 83,690 listed as inactive.

A 2021 examine by the College of Calgary’s College of Public Coverage mentioned almost 55 % of inactive wells have been silent for greater than 5 years, whereas greater than 5,000 have been inactive for no less than twenty years.

Alberta NDP MPW Kathleen Ganley known as the brand new provincial program fiscally irresponsible, noting that corporations are already required by regulation to wash up their very own wells.

“This quantities to an enormous switch of wealth from Alberta households to corporations that do not want it,” she mentioned in an announcement.

As for the {industry}’s response, an announcement from Canadian Affiliation of Petroleum Producers (CAPP) vice-president Brad Herald mentioned the group appears ahead to the session course of and “will work to make sure that the momentum constructed within the restoration of legacy websites in Alberta proceed.”

Article content material

“We’re nonetheless assessing this system introduced by the Alberta authorities,” Cenovus Vitality, one of many nation’s largest producers, mentioned in an announcement on Monday.

“We’ll decide how this may occasionally have an effect on our plans after we see extra particulars.”

Phil Hodge, CEO of junior gasoline producer Pine Cliff Vitality, mentioned he does not have many wells that may entry this system, however believes it would encourage some corporations to wash up extra advanced websites which have existed for years .

“It’s a laudable objective. I believe what is going on to occur is we will clear up plenty of websites if (it) continues. On the similar time, it hopefully stimulates much more exercise and drilling in Alberta,” mentioned Hodge.

Ember Sources CEO Doug Dafoe famous that the AER has made adjustments lately to make sure extra wells are cleaned up, akin to introducing a compulsory spending requirement, whereas the {industry}’s annual Orphan Effectively levy Affiliation – used to finance the cleansing of lacking wells. a present proprietor — is anticipated to just about double from final 12 months’s degree.

Article content material

As for the brand new pilot program of the province?

“It actually has minimal impression on me. However what I’d be extra involved (about) is the dialogue that comes out,” he mentioned.

“It is actually detrimental press for the {industry}, within the sense that persons are saying, ‘Wait a minute, you are supposed to do that,’ which I agree with 100%. Persons are alleged to deal with their obligations.”

Guthrie burdened particulars are nonetheless being developed. The pilot initiative will seemingly roll out someday within the spring or summer time.

“This program has not been arrange but,” he added.

“It is actually a profit to all Albertans and in the long run it clears these burdens sooner — and in the end that is the place we wish to go.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

cvarcoe@postmedia.com