Five big takeaways from Justin Trudeau’s testimony about foreign interference

Article content material

OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau provided a prolonged testimony on the Public Inquiry on Overseas Interference on Wednesday, throughout which he answered questions on what he knew or didn’t learn about alleged interference within the 2019 and 2021 elections.

Beneath are among the major takeaways of his testimony.

Article content material

Busing folks for nomination votes not a ‘smoking gun’

Article content material

Trudeau instructed the inquiry he didn’t obtain “sufficiently credible info” to take away Liberal candidate Han Dong from the 2019 election poll regardless of suspected irregularities and potential interference by China and stated the busing of seniors and overseas college students was no “smoking gun.”

“In hotly contested nominations, there are virtually at all times buses,” stated Trudeau in French, noting that he had buses of voters from the Italian-Canadian and Greek-Canadian communities in his personal nomination course of within the Montreal using of Papineau that he represents.

Dong admitted in his personal testimony that his spouse, who was his marketing campaign supervisor, paid for 2 buses of seniors to his nomination. However he stated he was not conscious who organized or paid for a bus of Mandarin-speaking worldwide college students to vote for him in his 2019 nomination race.

Trudeau stated in a pre-hearing interview with inquiry counsel that intelligence brokers “may not understand how nomination processes usually unfold” and that whereas “the buses appeared like a ‘smoking gun’ for some analysts; they weren’t for somebody who works in a political occasion.”

Article content material

Article content material

He doesn’t assume Conservatives misplaced races because of overseas interference

Trudeau stated he had no recollection of being knowledgeable of the alleged disinformation marketing campaign towards former Conservative chief Erin O’Toole and his candidate Kenny Chiu on the time of the 2021 election, however stated he’s skeptical that overseas interference had something to do with it.

He stated that that the Liberals received as a result of it “had higher candidates, ran higher campaigns, and since the rhetoric of the CPC (Conservative Celebration of Canada) in the direction of China had an impression on the bottom — not due to a disinformation marketing campaign,” learn his witness assertion.

Trudeau added that his workforce had a “nice floor sport” in Chiu’s using of Richmond, in British Columbia, because it had received it in 2015 and knew that “quite a lot of Chinese language Canadians had been turned off by Erin O’Toole’s notably aggressive positioning round China.”

Article content material

“Whether or not or not there was a Chinese language-language social media marketing campaign towards him, there was a gradual momentum that indicated that the LPC (Liberal Celebration of Canada) was going to do effectively with Chinese language Canadians, externally to any potential interference by China,” he stated in his assertion.

He stopped totally trusting overseas menace intelligence

Trudeau referenced a defective menace evaluation {that a} safety company did about an MP, one thing his chief of workers Katie Telford talked about in her testimony the day prior. He stated the incident, which occurred early in his tenure as prime minister, taught him “to not take all info as a right.”

One of many methods wherein this is able to come up, in keeping with his pre-witness testimony, was if he put ahead sure names of MPs to be elevated as parliamentary secretary or as minister.

He stated he would often observe the recommendation from the safety companies however, within the occasion he and Telford recalled, his workplace requested “additional verification of the knowledge.” Telford stated the company labored “all night time” to confirm its evaluation earlier than reversing it, suggesting that it was an pressing matter to take care of.

Article content material

“So being cautious and asking questions and pushing again on intelligence is one thing that he and his workforce discovered a really clear lesson on early on, and in his view, it has served them effectively,” learn Trudeau’s pre-testimony assertion to the inquiry.

‘Bragging’ by overseas diplomats doesn’t equal ‘doing’ interference

Trudeau spoke in imprecise phrases a couple of scenario talked about in one in every of Telford’s handwritten notes. In them, she referred to a overseas diplomat primarily based in Canada boasting to his or her superiors again dwelling about one thing that had apparently been achieved — conceivably some profitable interference.

Telford’s closely censored notes present that she was writing down examples of interference, corresponding to “amplifying CPC narrative”, presumably referring to the Communist Celebration of China, “threshold of interference” and “incorrect evaluation.” Beneath, she wrote “bragging isn’t doing.”

“Simply the truth that a overseas official was taking credit score for having delivered a specific end result under no circumstances meant that something that specific official did truly created the result,” stated Trudeau.

Article content material

“One can think about a diplomat in a far-off land wanting to write down again dwelling to say, ‘see, look what I did. Aren’t I good?’” he mimicked.

He was pissed off by intelligence leaks to the media

Trudeau expressed frustration concerning the leaks within the media “stemming from unsubstantiated and uncorroborated intelligence” that began within the fall of 2022, and together with his authorities’s restricted potential to right the file even when some info was “flat-out unsuitable,” he stated.

“There have been clear falsehoods and inaccuracies within the media reporting. However the problem of defending nationwide safety meant that we have been very a lot restricted in our potential to contradict the false allegations being made by the leaker,” he instructed the inquiry.

In his witness assertion, Trudeau noticed the leaks as “extraordinarily damaging to the boldness of Canadians within the democratic course of” and stated it was “notably irritating” as a result of the federal government had put in place “strong mechanisms to detect and fight” overseas interference.

But, the assertion added, “the federal government is painted as negligent within the media.” He stated that the leaks “illustrate the risks of drawing conclusions primarily based on a single piece of intelligence, with out ample context, and with none evaluation of its reliability.”

Nationwide Put up
calevesque@postmedia.com

Get extra deep-dive Nationwide Put up political protection and evaluation in your inbox with the Political Hack publication, the place Ottawa bureau chief Stuart Thomson and political analyst Tasha Kheiriddin get at what’s actually occurring behind the scenes on Parliament Hill each Wednesday and Friday, solely for subscribers. Join right here.

Our web site is the place for the most recent breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our newsletters right here.

Article content material