‘If we have been to do one thing, would we trial it for sooner or later? Would we trial it for a weekend? It must be a little bit of a check’
Article content material
As snow melts and shovels are put away, many Calgarians will flock to patios and outlets on seventeenth Avenue, whereas nonetheless having the ability to park — and drive — on the road.
Based mostly on the outcomes of a survey performed final yr and the quantity of stakeholders inside the seventeenth Ave. Enterprise Enchancment Space (BIA), it’s unlikely Calgarians will see a “car-free zone” on seventeenth Avenue this summer time, in keeping with BIA govt director Tulene Steiestol.
Commercial 2
Article content material
Article content material
Social media conversations a few car-free zone of seventeenth Avenue in latest weeks have alleged that noise of autos, significantly these with aftermarket exhausts, are making individuals flip away from patios alongside the street, stated Steiestol.
Shutting down the street to noise isn’t going to imply that companies are driving visitors, she stated, highlighting that their main focus is the success of companies inside the hall.
Steiestol stated that discuss of a closure to autos alongside seventeenth Avenue has come up many instances over time, however a flurry of social media posts and feedback in 2023 rekindled the talks of a possible car-free zone.
“We obtained a few cellphone calls and emails from members of the group, and particularly our enterprise group, going ‘did we begin this?’ as a enterprise enchancment space, and we didn’t.”
Certainly one of 15 BIAs that cowl about 6,000 companies within the metropolis, the seventeenth Ave. BIA has greater than 720 companies below its wing.
The survey, performed final summer time, requested companies inside hall for suggestions on the thought of a street closure. It was despatched out via their enterprise publication, which about 400 have been subscribed to.
Midday Information Roundup
Article content material
Commercial 3
Article content material
“What was overwhelming, is that they simply stated no,” Steiestol stated.
Of the 23 survey responses they obtained, seven have been in favour of a potential street closure, and 16 stated no.
Equal footing wanted between eating places, retail: restaurant proprietor
Inglewood has experimented with “car-free Sundays” in earlier years. Steiestol stated for seventeenth Avenue, any closure would wish to have a compelling motive for individuals to come back down, like an exercise or occasion.
Trolley 5 Brewpub proprietor Ernie Tsu stated a car-free zone would undoubtedly profit eating places, however there must be equal footing for retail as nicely.
He talked about parking as being “large” for each enterprise, whether or not it’s hospitality or retail.
“There may be loads of parking down right here, however not sufficient to remove the entire avenue parking. That might be a detriment, I feel, to companies,” stated Tsu.
Peaseblossoms Flowers on eleventh Road is a member of the seventeenth Ave. BIA, and proprietor Marika Styba stated her enterprise has seen a 60 per cent discount in parking close by as a consequence of mobility enhancements and bike lanes.
When building on the road started, Styba stated she misplaced 25 per cent of enterprise, adopted by about 10 per cent losses in subsequent years.
Commercial 4
Article content material
“I principally went from two full-time workers, and I now have (one) part-time workers particular person — I’ve needed to fill within the gaps,” she stated. “It’s fairly miserable, as a result of I’m always having to search for different alternatives outdoors my neighbourhood.”
She’s needed to get artistic by doing deliveries of on-line orders, together with attending the Bearspaw Farmers Market in the summertime.
“It burns me that I’ve to pack up my store and drive to a different municipality to get sufficient enterprise to remain afloat.”
Additionally on eleventh Road, Nikos Pizza proprietor Nick Doikas skilled a 65 per cent drop in in-store gross sales. General, he stated his revenues have truly grown as a consequence of supply platforms like Skip the Dishes.
’seventeenth Avenue is a spot that individuals need to come’
Visitors volumes alongside seventeenth Avenue varies from 10,000 autos per day on the east finish close to Macleod Path as much as roughly 25,000 autos per day additional west, stated Tony Churchill, performing supervisor of mobility operations with the Metropolis of Calgary.
“Fairly a variability there, however these are fairly typical of high-volume arterials,” he stated.
Like loads of different most important streets, seventeenth Avenue has many alternative capabilities, stated Churchill, akin to “a spot for individuals to come back to and spend time at.”
Commercial 5
Article content material
As a connection via downtown, the street additionally has to accommodate transit, motion of products, individuals, and parking, Churchill stated.
“There’s so much happening on that street proper of method, and it’s exhausting to handle.”
Steiestol stated that if street closures have been to come back into play, programming must match the inconvenience, and the influence it might have on companies and their revenues.
“If we have been to do one thing, would we trial it for sooner or later? Would we trial it for a weekend? It must be a little bit of a check.”
She famous considerations like what it might imply for transit customers, detours, and residents of the Beltline, who can be impacted by heavier volumes of visitors by street closures.
Churchill echoed lots of the similar factors, and in addition talked about the necessity for supply drivers to have the ability to cease, decide up meals, and ship to residences.
“Positively we all know that seventeenth Avenue is a spot that individuals need to come, and so we’ve got to make it possible for they’ll try this in quite a lot of methods,” he stated.
Steiestol stated, “There’s not a one-size-fits-all, as a result of it’s so complicated with the variety of who is actually impacted — the group at giant and in addition the enterprise group.
Commercial 6
Article content material
“A photograph that appears nice on Instagram of a street closure, with individuals actively out and having fun with the sunshine and nice climate; what does it truly imply although, to the underside line of the companies on both facet of that avenue?
“If it’s not seventeenth Avenue, is there someplace else in our hall the place this actually may work?”
She talked about that as a result of eleventh Road has already misplaced some parking with the addition of motorbike lanes, they’re discussing if it might be extra of a “pure” match.
“Their companies are already down, they’re actually feeling the pinch, however may we flip that into one thing the place there may be some type of programming that’s actively supporting them, and driving extra individuals, extra consciousness?”
Article content material
