Father of woman who wants assisted suicide seeking court intervention

Article content material

Attorneys for a Calgary man making an attempt to dam his grownup daughter’s assisted suicide say a judicial assessment of her approval must be carried out.

However counsel for the lady, who can’t be recognized underneath a courtroom order, argued Monday the daddy has no standing in interfering with an permitted medical resolution.

Article content material

Lawyer Sarah Miller, who acts for the daddy, named in courtroom data as W.V., mentioned an injunction granted to the dad the day earlier than the lady’s assisted suicide was to happen on Feb. 1 must be prolonged till a judicial assessment can happen.

Article content material

Miller argued the Medical Help in Dying (MAID) approval her shopper’s 27-year-old daughter, M.V., obtained must be completely reviewed.

“As W.V. explains, M.V. suffers from autism and probably different undiagnosed maladies that don’t fulfill the eligibility standards for MAID,” Miller mentioned in her written temporary for Justice Colin Feasby.

Together with autism, the Courtroom of King’s Bench choose was advised the lady additionally suffers from consideration deficit hyperactivity dysfunction and her father doesn’t imagine she is in want of MAID to alleviate her struggling.

The daughter utilized for MAID final yr and initially obtained approval from considered one of two medical doctors. She then utilized to a 3rd doctor who additionally permitted the process.

“There are real considerations with respect to impartiality,” Miller mentioned.

The lawyer mentioned there are additionally points regarding whether or not the affected person has been topic to undue affect in coming to the conclusion she desires medical professionals to terminate her life.

“There’s no proof earlier than this courtroom that she has an irremediable situation,” Miller mentioned.

Article content material

Article content material

In her written temporary, she mentioned if Feasby finds he doesn’t have the flexibility to judicially assessment the choice, then her shopper would solely be capable to carry authorized motion after his daughter’s demise.

“If this courtroom determines that it doesn’t have the flexibility to judicially assessment MAID approvals by (Alberta Heath Providers), it’ll create an insulated system of presidency motion, whereby the legality of AHS’s selections is proof against assessment upfront of the affected person’s demise,” she mentioned.

However attorneys Austin Paladeau and Evan Jovanovic mentioned the choice to resort to MAID was a medical difficulty between the lady and her medical doctors.

“It might have the impact of permitting one particular person to impose their beliefs on one other,” Jovanovic advised Feasby.

Article content material

He mentioned whereas they sympathized with the daddy’s scenario, he doesn’t have the appropriate to intervene.

“Whereas that is unhappy, it doesn’t give him the appropriate to maintain his daughter alive in opposition to her needs,” Jovanovic mentioned.

He mentioned it got here right down to a problem of their shopper’s “elementary proper . . . and bodily integrity.”

Attorneys for Alberta Well being Providers mentioned their shopper had no say within the resolution and the physique shouldn’t be topic to any judicial assessment.

“Physicians usually are not staff of AHS,” John Siddons mentioned.

In reserving his resolution, Feasby mentioned it’s a posh case that may undoubtedly find yourself within the Courtroom of Attraction.

“I don’t suggest to take a very long time with my resolution, however I discover this case extra vexing than most,” he mentioned.

KMartin@postmedia.com

X: @KMartinCourts

Article content material