Proposal to ban ward budget-funded billboard greetings rejected

Article content material

A Metropolis of Calgary committee rejected a bylaw modification Thursday to ban councillors from utilizing their ward budgets to fund personalised vacation greetings on billboards — a observe one committee member argued is a delicate approach for councillors to marketing campaign on the general public dime by boosting their title and facial recognition.

However despite the fact that her proposed modification failed in a 3-3 tie, Coun. Jasmine Mian stated she plans to carry the identical dialogue to council later this month.

Article content material

Article content material

On the tail finish of Thursday’s council providers committee assembly, Mian moved to amend councillors’ budgets and bills bylaw, stopping councillors from utilizing their taxpayer-funded ward budgets to promote personalised vacation greetings on billboards.

“Utilizing billboards this manner is a tactic employed by provincial and federal representatives to extend title and face recognition, however the distinction is these representatives have constituency associations that fundraise cash to help these initiatives,” she stated.

“Municipal representatives solely have ward budgets, and members of council, on this time period, have acquired public criticism for spending tons of and even 1000’s of {dollars} on these billboards, as a result of it’s seen as a poor use of taxpayer {dollars} by residents.”

The modification in the end failed 3-3, with Couns. Raj Dhaliwal, Dan McLean and Sonya Sharp voting in opposition, whereas Couns. Terry Wong, Andre Chabot and Mian voted in favour.

‘Nitpicking’: Opposing councillors critique modification

Throughout debate, Sharp argued the wording of Mian’s modification was too obscure, because it didn’t outline “billboard” and didn’t exclude the identical observe for utilizing mail-outs, brochures, or different public signage.

Article content material

Article content material

It could even be comparatively simple to search out loopholes by attaching another message onto a vacation greeting, Sharp identified, comparable to promoting an upcoming city corridor or including an internet hyperlink for a metropolis service.

McLean agreed the modification was “nitpicking,” and added that as elected officers, councillors have a duty to speak effectively needs to their constituents.

“MLAs, Members of Parliament, they do that out of their constituency workplaces and out of their budgets,” he stated. “We’re elected officers as effectively (and this) simply comes with the territory of the job.”

Dhaliwal identified that Calgarians who observe spiritual holidays, comparable to Ramadan or Diwali, really feel extra included once they see public effectively needs towards these celebrations from their council consultant.

He additionally stated it’s as much as councillors to abide by the code of conduct bylaw and reply for a way they spend their ward budgets.

“I believe we’re attempting to repair one thing that’s not damaged,” he stated.

Article content material

‘Not an acceptable use of cash’

Wong advised tweaking the modification additional by altering the language to ban funding billboard greetings with ward budgets in an election yr, however Mian stated she wasn’t eager about that suggestion.

“It’s one thing the general public has raised as an inappropriate use of taxpayer cash and it ought to finish,” she stated throughout her closing argument.

Although the merchandise was rejected on the committee degree, Mian stated she nonetheless plans to introduce the modification on the common assembly of metropolis council on March 19.

“This isn’t an acceptable use of cash and it does have a profit to the incumbents, (who) have already got a really vital benefit,” she stated, referring to the arguments in opposition to her movement as “psychological gymnastics.”

Article content material