Breakenridge: The roller-coaster ride of provincial budgets continues

Article content material

It’s not unusual within the aftermath of an election for a brand new authorities to embark on a dramatically totally different coverage course whereas denouncing the earlier strategy as reckless and irresponsible. It’s fairly unusual, although, to see that from a re-elected authorities.

But, that was the takeaway from the premier’s deal with to Albertans final week. The pre-election price range loaded with file ranges of spending topped off with a marketing campaign tax lower promise is exactly the type of strategy that Alberta should now abandon. And we’re to belief the federal government that succumbed to that temptation a 12 months in the past to be the guardians in opposition to such impulsive and imprudent behaviour sooner or later.

Article content material

Article content material

Albertans are proper to be skeptical. It’s not the primary time we’ve heard discuss of getting off the royalty roller-coaster and we’d be silly to imagine will probably be the final. The premier’s not unsuitable to lament the issue of Alberta governments eager to have it each methods with low taxes and excessive ranges of spending, however she’s simply as responsible of it.

It might sound harsh to be important of an elected official who’s prepared to acknowledge an necessary and inconvenient fact. Conversely, although, no authorities ought to get a cross on such a cynical flip-flop. As College of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe famous in the course of the election: “Any proposal that lowers income or will increase expenditures will increase our reliance on pure useful resource revenues.” The premier was undoubtedly conscious of this reality and but she pressed forward.

Now, the UCP’s promised tax lower — which we have been instructed would “increase the economic system” and “present significant, well timed tax reduction to Albertans at a time once they want it most” — is indefinitely on maintain. The premier stated it could be “phased in responsibly” down the highway, but it surely’s laborious to see how the fiscal panorama goes to look considerably totally different in a 12 months or two.

Article content material

Article content material

It’s fairly a job the federal government has laid out for itself. As famous within the premier’s deal with, the 2023 price range “required about $16 billion of useful resource royalties simply to steadiness our roughly $70-billion provincial price range.” That’s an enormous deficit absent that useful resource income, and the premier can also be promising no spending cuts, no new taxes and no deficit. Plus, we’re not but debt-free.

(It was additionally fascinating to listen to the premier make the argument in opposition to increased taxes whereas additionally touting Norway’s success in increase an enormous wealth fund. Norway has a lot increased tax charges, along with having a 25 per cent gross sales tax. It’s unclear whether or not this can be a mannequin to repeat or to shun.)

It’s really a disgrace that our Heritage Fund is nowhere close to the extent it might be. A gradual annual stream of $10 billion or $20 billion in curiosity from such a fund could be an excellent alternative for the volatility of annual useful resource revenues. A want and a dedication to reaching that’s fairly laudable certainly.

Article content material

This week’s price range will give deeper perception into the dedication to this new path. However what will probably be extra revealing is the 2027 price range, which can come down on the eve of the following provincial election. If that price range avoids dear pre-election goodies, and it’s adopted by an election marketing campaign that eschews costly guarantees, it should characterize a robust sign as to the federal government’s dedication and intent.

After all, it’s additionally honest to ask why such a disciplined fiscal strategy has not been the centrepiece of any profitable election marketing campaign in current reminiscence. If governments are snug tabling budgets with excessive spending and low taxes, it have to be as a result of they’re satisfied it’s what the voters need. A part of the take a look at right here falls on all of us.

Nevertheless it’s not unreasonable to count on honesty and consistency. Time will inform whether or not this premier is ready to ship that.

“Afternoons with Rob Breakenridge” airs weekdays from 12:30 to three p.m. on QR Calgary

rob.breakenridge@corusent.com

Twitter: @RobBreakenridge

Article content material