Public fury sends bag bylaw packing — but Gondek stays on wrong side

Article content material

Metropolis council despatched the hated single-use bylaw on a demise march Tuesday, by a startling rely of 8-7 on the primary vote, and 10-5 on the principle.

A public listening to have to be held in Might. There can be arguments for “bettering” the bylaw. However it ought to be left to relaxation in everlasting peace.

Article content material

This was greater than the approaching doom of a wildly unpopular bylaw that turns even paper baggage into an environmental enemy.

Article content material

It was additionally the primary large crack within the Gondek majority on council. The mayor, who may normally depend on seven different votes, was left with solely 4 allies.

The remainder of her crew went to the anti-bylaw gang of six that had change into her unofficial opposition.

It exhibits that an utility of frequent sense from offended voters can overwhelm sclerotic metropolis corridor.

With the approval of solely 30 per cent of Calgarians, Gondek will now have a tough time rallying council to her causes.

Reasonably than voting towards a movement responding to public opinion, she would have accomplished herself extra good by going with the highly effective movement.

However no, there she is, just about alone. On a serious situation like this, that hasn’t occurred to any mayor I’ve recognized going all the best way again to Al Duerr within the Nineties.

On Tuesday, Gondek hauled the bylaw earlier than council. It was an apparent effort to placate opinion and in addition push the tax situation into the background.

One councillor after one other mentioned they’ve had lots of of emails from individuals livid concerning the new guidelines that levy fees even for paper baggage.

“This blew fireworks out of the water,” mentioned Coun. Sonya Sharp, referring to the uproar over final 12 months’s resolution, quickly reversed, to ban fireworks on Canada Day.

Article content material

Article content material

When metropolis bureaucrats make their case, you possibly can see this bylaw was put over on gullible councillors. These officers are deep into behaviour-shaping and social management.

Most of us are inclined to assume paper baggage are OK as a result of they’re compostable and biodegradable, proper? Give them a while and so they return to Mom Earth.

However this bylaw would positive a retailer clerk $250 for handing you a paper bag with out being requested, or failing to cost 15 cents when you do ask.

One official defined why paper baggage are the brand new enemy.

They’re “means simpler to recycle however we have to consider the life-cycle price of that paper bag,” this individual advised council.

“If we are able to deliver our personal bag from house, then we don’t have to fret concerning the timber that have been reduce down and the logging vehicles that bombed alongside the logging roads scaring recreationalists, and the pulp mills and the storage and the transportation of these paper baggage.”

Article content material

So, the goal wasn’t simply landfill congestion or objects that by no means biodegrade. Metropolis corridor’s goal went all the best way to the forestry trade.

These bureaucrats are deeply dedicated to compelled and escalating change.

“There can be preliminary discomfort as we construct new habits,” one other official mentioned.

“It can take our collective effort and require a shift in behaviours.”

Such bylaws “have been confirmed to incentivize behaviour change.”

This perspective is driving individuals nuts for good cause. Through the pandemic, we spent two years obeying authorities guidelines.

Many individuals have been OK with that — it was a harmful sickness, in any case. Others have been livid at harm to their companies, lack of mobility and the academic hurt to their children.

However hardly anyone of no matter view got here out of that bleak time with joyful ideas about authorities.

Removed from fading away, this sense has metastasized into basic distrust of presidency guidelines and mandates.

Now metropolis council spits out a bylaw full of choosy, fussy particulars, and the insulting assumption that we have to be compelled into correct behaviour.

Article content material

Politicians who didn’t see the fierce response coming are really clueless. They haven’t any sense of their metropolis.

The identical councillor who introduced the movement towards the bag bylaw additionally launched one to cut back the 7.8 per cent property tax hike by two factors.

Marc Henry, of pollster ThinkHQ, discovered a development final December that ought to terrify the councillors who resist such measures.

Those that opposed the tax hike truly rose in recognition. Those who favoured it slid even decrease.

The query for all of them, Henry says, is, “What aspect of the road do you need to be standing on?

“Do you need to be on the aspect that cares about what residents assume, or do you need to be on the aspect that makes selections you imagine are finest for individuals, no matter whether or not they need them or not?”

On Tuesday, a number of councillors truly obtained that message. Not the mayor.

Fairly quickly, 30 per cent recognition may look good to her.

Don Braid’s column seems repeatedly within the Herald

X: @DonBraid

Article content material