Emotional debate over Freedom Convoy protests reopens after Emergencies Act ruling

Article content material

OTTAWA — A decide’s ruling that the federal Liberals had been unjustified in utilizing emergency legislation to quell a weeks-long protest in Ottawa has left the administrator of a downtown church feeling the court docket disregarded infringements of her rights.

In a call launched Tuesday, Federal Courtroom Justice Richard Mosley stated the federal government’s invocation of the Emergencies Act in February 2022 was unreasonable and led to violation of the constitutional proper of free expression.

Article content material

Article content material

The Canadian Civil Liberties Affiliation, an applicant within the case, stated the ruling serves discover that even in occasions of disaster, when feelings are operating excessive, no authorities is above the legislation and that primary rights and freedoms have to be upheld.

Vivian Leir, the long-time administrator of a Presbyterian church close to Parliament Hill, stated she was dismayed by the court docket resolution after what she skilled through the three-week protest in downtown Ottawa.

The Freedom Convoy protest, initially seen as an indication in opposition to COVID-19 well being restrictions, attracted folks with a wide range of grievances in opposition to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and the Liberal authorities.

Blaring truck horns, diesel fumes and makeshift encampments prompted many companies to briefly shut their doorways and aggravated downtown residents, a few of whom had been harassed.

Disgruntled protesters additionally blockaded key border crossings to the USA.

The Emergencies Act allowed for momentary measures together with regulation and prohibition of public assemblies, the designation of safe locations, route to banks to freeze belongings and a ban on assist for contributors.

Article content material

Article content material

Leir stated the court docket ruling has completed nothing to alter her perception that the federal government was justified in invoking the emergency powers.

“On the time, when the federal authorities introduced within the Emergencies Act, it was an awesome reduction to myself and I feel lots of the residents of Ottawa,” she stated in an interview Wednesday.

“To listen to that they didn’t suppose it was justified when clearly nothing was being completed in regards to the scenario, it form of hurts.”

Leir testified within the prison trial of two Freedom Convoy organizers about how overwhelmed she felt by the variety of big-rig vehicles and near-constant horn honking that accompanied the protest. That prison trial continues to be ongoing.

A proposed $290-million class-action lawsuit in opposition to convoy organizers on behalf of downtown Ottawa residents, employees and enterprise house owners can be nonetheless unfolding in Ontario court docket, stated Paul Champ, lawyer for the lead plaintiff within the case.

Article content material

Reflecting on Mosley’s ruling, Champ stated Wednesday that invoking the Emergencies Act is one thing that must be reserved for extraordinary circumstances, involving dire threats to the safety of Canada, “and I don’t suppose that we had been essentially there.”

“The court docket undoubtedly discovered that there was an unacceptable breakdown in public order in Ottawa, however felt that the Emergencies Act, or not less than the way in which it was invoked, was a blunt software to attempt to handle it,” Champ stated.

“The large takeaway is that it’s a particularly excessive threshold.”

The federal authorities has stated it disagrees with Mosley’s resolution and plans to attraction, which means the case is more likely to be earlier than the courts for a lot of extra months and even years.

The Public Order Emergency Fee, which carried out a compulsory overview after invocation of the emergency legislation, issued 56 suggestions final February on enhancing the response to large-scale public order occasions.

Public Security Minister Dominic LeBlanc is predicted to supply the federal government’s full response to Rouleau’s findings subsequent month.

The Emergencies Act additionally requires a joint committee of parliamentarians to overview the federal government’s measures and report again to the Home of Commons and the Senate.

That committee was struck in March 2022 and has met greater than two dozen occasions, however has but to file a considerable report.

The committee is ready for paperwork and proof to be translated into each official languages earlier than the fabric might be thought of.

The parliamentarians are anticipated to fulfill when the Home resumes to query a Privy Council Workplace consultant in regards to the challenge.

Our web site is the place for the newest breaking information, unique scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and join our every day e-newsletter, Posted, right here.

Article content material