Police officer’s bid to seal interview on fatal hotel shooting fails

Article content material

A Calgary police officer’s try to be interviewed concerning the deadly capturing of a person in a metropolis lodge that was withheld from a evaluation board has been rejected.

Article content material

const. Robert Brauer has argued the discharge of necessary statements he made concerning the 2015 capturing of Anthony Heffernan by a police colleague to the Alberta Regulation Enforcement Assessment Board (LERB) was unconstitutional.

Article content material

However the LERB ​​rejected his utility and dominated that the officer’s statements didn’t have immunity underneath the province’s police legislation.

“Part 20 (of the Police Act) offers the council the ability to require a chief of police to provide to the council earlier than an attraction listening to copies of all investigative reviews, statements, correspondence or different paperwork or issues referring to the matter lie. ,” the three-person LERB ​​panel concluded in its February 6 resolution.

“The board will proceed to a listening to the place the events’ submissions on whether or not the council ought to enable the interviews as a part of the document will likely be thought of by the council.”

Article content material

Household important of alleged lack of transparency, accountability

Heffernan’s household has been sharply important of what they name the shortage of transparency and accountability of the police within the controversial capturing of their beloved one.

They appealed to the LERB ​​after making complaints to the CPS concerning the capturing which they declare was pointless.

On March 16, 2015, 4 officers, together with Brauer, entered Anthony Heffernan’s room on the Tremendous 8 Motel — at 3030 Barlow Path NE — after a employees member reported that he was not responding to requests to take a look at.

The officers mentioned it appeared that the person had been utilizing medicine and had acted aggressively in direction of them.

Officer has not been charged in Heffernan’s demise

Heffernan (27) was arrested by Const. Maurice McLoughlin, who the Alberta Critical Incident Response Crew really helpful be charged in his demise.

Article content material

However Alberta Crown prosecutors declined to press prices, saying there wasn’t sufficient proof to convict.

And in his personal evaluation of the case, Calgary Police Chief Mark Neufeld mentioned as a result of McLoughlin resigned from the service final Could, he may now not be disciplined.

In its February 6 ruling, the LERB ​​famous that it notified the events within the case in January 2022 that it believed officers had management over directed explanatory reviews, however not over directed interviews reminiscent of Brauer’s , which they need to then present with copies by Jan. 21 of final yr.

Article content material

LERB says Brauer’s problem is just not related, untimely

It was then that Brauer launched his constitutional problem, arguing that on this case the availability of the Police Act cited by the LERB ​​shouldn’t have any impact and that the board lacks jurisdiction when laws referring to the Canadian Constitution of Rights and Freedoms.

However the LERB ​​decided that the argument was not related as a result of it didn’t contain the attainable lack of “life, liberty and safety of the individual” as required within the constitution.

It additionally mentioned Brauer’s problem is untimely as a result of it’s not recognized how the LERB ​​will use his statements.

“The mere submission of the directed statements to the council doesn’t routinely imply that the statements will likely be used towards the respondents for a legal objective,” the LERB ​​mentioned.

“The council is of the opinion that the directed statements needs to be included within the document with a view to be ready to determine whether or not a number of of the respondent officers’ actions might represent a federal or provincial offence.”

BKaufmann@postmedia.com

Twitter: @BillKaufmannjrn